Downtown is the other half of the anniversary map, and it has been rebuilt in the last decade into something worth booking a night in. The Antlers at 4 South Cascade Avenue stands on the site where Palmer put the city's original 1883 hotel of that name — the third building to carry it — and it looks straight down Pikes Peak Avenue at the mountain the street is named for. The Mining Exchange at 8 South Nevada Avenue is a converted 1902 stock exchange where Cripple Creek gold was traded, with the vault still in the basement. Kinship Landing at 415 South Nevada is the newer boutique end of the market. West of town, The Cliff House at Pikes Peak at 306 Cañon Avenue in Manitou Springs has been receiving guests since the 1870s, when they came for the mineral springs, and Briarhurst Manor a few blocks away was Dr. William Bell's own house before it became one of the region's long-standing special-occasion dining rooms. Glen Eyrie at 3820 North 30th Street — Palmer's Tudor castle, now a conference center run by the Navigators — is where a surprising number of local couples married, and its English teas make it an anniversary destination in its own right. Every one of these takes a front-desk hand-off; none of them will find a guest for you without a surname.
For couples who live here, the anniversary delivery goes to a house, and the houses are the difficult part of this city's geography. The long-married belt is the southwest: the Broadmoor neighborhood, Broadmoor Bluffs, Skyway and Cheyenne Cañon in 80906, where the streets climb the mountain in switchbacks, driveways are steep and long, and a January delivery can meet an inch of ice that the flat parts of town never saw. Above Garden of the Gods, Cedar Heights is gated with an attendant, so a gate code or a resident phone call is required rather than helpful. Kissing Camels, the gated enclave wrapped around the Garden of the Gods Resort's golf course, works the same way. On the north side, Flying Horse in 80921 and the newer 80924 streets have club-and-gate arrangements of their own. The older flat neighborhoods are easier and often more rewarding: the Old North End in 80903, where the 1890s houses above Colorado College still have the deep porches they were built with, Patty Jewett in 80907 around the golf course the city has owned for a century, and Cheyenne Meadows and the Ivywild blocks in 80905. Put a recipient mobile number on any hillside or gated address and the driver will arrange the hand-off instead of guessing at a call box.
Restaurants are where anniversary plans most often go sideways, so here is the honest version. Most Colorado Springs restaurants will not accept a floral delivery in advance of a reservation — there is nowhere to keep it, the host stand is not a cloakroom, and a bouquet sitting by a service door for two hours arrives wilted. That includes the downtown rooms couples actually book for a fortieth: MacKenzie's Chop House on South Tejon, The Famous on North Tejon, the Broadmoor's own dining rooms, Briarhurst in Manitou. If you want flowers in the picture, send them to the house that morning or to the hotel front desk for late afternoon, then go to dinner. If the evening is at the Broadmoor or the Garden of the Gods Resort, the bell desk will place an arrangement in the room before turndown, which is the version of the surprise that actually works. The one restaurant scenario that does work is a private event room booked in your name, where staff are already handling table setting — call the venue first and ask, then tell the studio what they said. It is also worth knowing that the classic Colorado Springs anniversary outings — the Cog Railway up Pikes Peak from Ruxton Avenue in Manitou, Seven Falls in the box canyon above the Broadmoor, a sunrise walk through Garden of the Gods — all end with a drive home, which is one more argument for having the flowers already waiting.